Phil advises Ben to fight back;[16] soon after, Ben attacks Jordan with a spanner, leaving him with a fractured skull. Ben and Halfway Paul Coker was the son of the late Laurie Coker and the grandson of Les and Pam Coker. Ben and Abi decide to find their own home after realising they can no longer stay with Phil after Sharon leaves him. Paul Coker was in EastEnders from June 2015 until September 2016, but what happened to him? Hurt and confused, Ben asks Abi's sister Lauren Branning (Jacqueline Jossa), who works for Luke's firm, Weyland & Co, about the project but she does not know about it. And it doesnt scare him anymore, the prospect of getting married. 2. [5][6] She abuses Ben physically and psychologically, from burning him with a hot spoon, also attempting to spoil his friendship with Abi Branning (Lorna Fitzgerald) when she discovers this, to threatening to kill Phil if Ben tells anyone about her actions. Car crash kills 2 callum takes his first ski trip to the beautiful village of morzine, ben is the filthy local he meets on the plane. After their first time, Callum gets a bit emotional, and Ben panics. Paul arrives in Walford after travelling in Turkey, and angers Ben Mitchell when he accidentally knocks over Lola Pearce and then flirts with Ben. Ben just shrugs and the guy turns back around and waits for his drink. Desperate to impress his dad and prevent a civil war breaking out in Walford, Ben kidnaps Callum and forces him to reluctantly share the burden of their families' addiction to crime and one-upping each other. When the realisation of his infidelity occurs, Clay believed Callum feels ashamed for his treatment of Whitney. If you proceed you have agreed that you are willing to see such content. Ben Mitchell (played by Max Bowden) has struggled to cope in EastEnders in the aftermath of the homophobic attack on himself, Callum Highway (Tony Clay), Ash Panesar (Gurlaine Kaur Garcha), Eve. In fact, he wants it. Ben does dispose of the wrench but further blackmails Martin with footage of him stealing a car. Not today, not tomorrow, and definitely not in a weeks time. He confronts Martin and the next morning, he tells Martin that he is sorry for what he has put him through and that Stacey is free to return to Walford. Paul has been dead for almost six years. crack Fanfic eastenders story. Ben ends his relationship with Paul, leaving Paul heartbroken. Hes laying on his back in bed in his and Callums bedroom. [6][7][8] Phil and Stella become engaged. Later Ben and Paul met up for a drink and Les encouraged Paul to tell Ben how he felt. A man, training to join the police. Read more: EastEnders: Gray will kill his boss Laura, say fans. Ben is the one on the left and callum is the one . Phil's stepped up, Ben's backed down. [76], On 2 October 2017, it was announced that Ben would be written out of the soap again as part of an "explosive storyline". youwilgetaroused; sexytime; benmitchell +19 more # 15. Reid was written out of the series in 2017 and Ben departed on 12 January 2018. A little look back over Ben's relationships. A collection of one shots about everyone's favourite couple, Ballum :), #8 Christmas Day at the Mitchell household. Realistic Short Stories. Paul Coker Ben contemplates ignoring him completely but relents. Happy Meal in tow, Ben scans for a seat. He deemed Ben a "very complex character" and said, "we will see a softer side to Ben when he returns, but the character has evolved. He then gets a job at Dean Wicks's hair salon, Blades. Les encourages Paul to tell Ben his feelings, which he does, saying Ben must choose who he really wants and who he really is. When Phil is later sent to hospital and informed that he will be dead within 12 months unless he has a liver transplant, Ben, alongside Sharon and Jay, refuse to visit him, and Sharon has him change the locks on the house so Phil cannot enter when he is discharged. Will they be able to thwart it? Coronation Street fans shocked to discover how old Samia Longchambons daughter is, Emmerdale spoilers: Moira left heartbroken as Cain destroys their family, Emmerdale fans go wild as Dean Andrews shares date night pic as he prepares for dream wedding, Katie Price shows off the results of her biggest-ever boob job in tiny white crop top, Catherine, Princess of Wales pays subtle nod to Queen and Princess Diana as she stuns in red today, Dancing On Ice: Siva Kaneswaran fights back tears as he reveals Tom Parker tribute this weekend. Following Luke's death and Willmott-Brown's eventual downfall, Phil joins Aidan in a planned heist and they use The Arches to steal the money. Ben Mitchell is a fictional character from the BBC soap opera EastEnders, who has been played by six different actors since his on-screen birth on 21 March 1996. To protect Halfway from the Mitchells, Ben breaks up with Halfway, claiming that he does not love him. Ben Finds Out Paul is Dead | EastEnders EastEnders 341K subscribers Subscribe 770 78K views 2 years ago After Ben and his boyfriend Paul suffer a homophobic attack, Ben is sat down by. The two later share a kiss. Thought it was about time I actually wrote it. Nine year old Ben and five year old Sophie live at their brothers house with his wife, Jane, and children, Lucy, Peter and Bobby for a short while. Work Search: A bolt of lightning comes into his life one afternoon and who knows why but one things is for sure, he can't let him go now that he's got it. tip: katekyou "alternate universe" sort:>words. Sorry, didnt mean anything by it, just that Ive never seen one really, a musical that is. Ben and Callum DCI Marsden does not believe him at first, but he is later arrested for murder. In 2021, Simon was released from Prison after serving five years inside for Paul's murder. 2015-2016: Relationship with Ben Mitchell. [15] Questioned as to why he hurt Louise, Ben claims that Jordan is bullying him. Ben can only see the back of his head but by the way his shoulders dip, the bloke seems a little embarrassed. +9 more # 17. [89], Ben as played by Jones received generally negative reviews from critics. Realising that Ben is a risk to the project being exposed, Luke ends their relationship. Last Appearance Ben tells Peggy and Phil he is coping despite being bullied by Cal Childs (Danny Barnham), and when the Mitchell family discovers this Ben asks them not to visit him. On Christmas Eve, after hearing identical stories from Keanu and Sharon about a hotel, Phil works out that Keanu is the father and Ben vows to have him killed. After finding Les's tie at Claudette's house and being given conflicting explanations from her and Les, Pam leaves to stay with her sister. Paul tells Pam that Les is having an affair, and she tries to confront Claudette, but loses her nerve and tells Paul not to mention it again, before later admitting that he is right. Giving you a large when you only paid for a small, reckon you are in there mate. Grace Dent of The Guardian wrote several negative opinion pieces on the character, and contacted the BBC with a list of suggestions for humorous storylines in which he could be killed off. Paul Coker was in EastEnders from June 2015 until September 2016, but what happened to him? But he believed that there is a softer side to Ben which he hoped could be fully explored. To give himself more time, Ben books tickets for Abi to visit a friend on holiday, and then tells Paul he loves him back. Phil, who was told by Louise's mother Lisa Fowler (Lucy Benjamin) that Sharon's unborn child is not his, coerces Ben and Keanu to kidnap Jack, who he thinks is the father of the baby. [11] In retaliation, Ben burns Louise's hand the same way Stella burnt his. So why does it feel like a kick in the teeth? Coronation Street spoilers: Beth and Kirk over after shock revelation? After a five-year absence from the series, Charlie Jones assumed the role of Ben in 2006. Paul secures the job after Lola leaves, while Vincent discovers evidence of the affair. They get into a passionate embrace and begin an affair. Hot Chocolate boy, Callum Ben reminds himself, moves the bag out of the way and Ben sits down, ready to ignore his reluctant table companion. But their "electric" kiss scene sent "fans wild". PM. Ben and Callum In celebration, they spend a night out together, and are not seen again the next day. Ben tries to reason with Phil, who wants to kill the father, but relents and agrees to help Phil. tip: austen words:10000-50000 sort:title, Trigger .warning- Suicidal thoughts / attempt/rape. Spanning for 35 years, EastEnders has gone on to portray its finest storylines over the years, with Ian Beale, Kathy Beale, Dot Cotton, Phil Mitchell and Sharon as the longest serving. Callum is an undertaker and Ben is "This is not the end of the book. He subsequently took boxing lessons, and TV Mag's Gemma Quade noted that Ben "refuse[d] to take the coward's way out" and flee the country with his father, but nonetheless was reduced to tears upon receiving a custodial sentence. It's been 7 months since Ben was forced to leave Walford in the dead of night after one of his and Phils jobs went even more tits up than usual. [12] He later locks Louise in a summerhouse for a day in May 2010, then pretends to find her to earn approval from his father. Ben went down a very dark path, and took drugs. [62] Despite being one of the most expensive stunts ever filmed by a soap opera, the episode drew EastEnders' lowest ever audience share and second lowest ratings due to a scheduling conflict with ITV's Emmerdale. [81] Their involvement begins when Ben witnesses Callum injuring himself to avoid going back to the army. it was stuck with me. He knows hes hurting Callum in the process, knows hes helping to make them both feel bad, but he cant seem to work out a way around it. Relationships/Known relatives Eventually Ben spots an empty seat, just his luck, it is opposite Hot Chocolate boy, who is now taking the smallest sips possible from his large drink. Ben then resumes his relationship with Paul with the support of most of his friends and family. The cashier doesnt appreciate the comment, judging by the look she levels Ben with. [92] Dent suggested that Phil and Ian's fighting over custody of Ben would turn him into "the next Jeffrey Dahmer",[93] and in an article on the future of Britain's soap opera adolescents, noted that: "Albert Square will no doubt reap what it's sown with tiny, cursed, abused, accident-prone, 11-year-old Ben Mitchell. tip: hetalia f/f sort:kudos. However, he later witnesses Stacey Fowler (Lacey Turner) attack Phil with a wrench, to stop the latter from killing her husband Martin Fowler (James Bye). A few days later, Halfway questions Ben about his encounter with Jack and where their relationship is going. And yet, still, he can't help thinking what if. Ben threatens to have Stacey and their kids killed if she does not stay away and if Martin does not continue working for him. Paul told Ben about his feelings, but Ben stayed with Abi when she told him she was pregnant. However, that evening, Ben and his henchmen kidnap Martin and hang him off the railway bridge, just as Martin did to Ben when he was younger. Ben continues to feel angst towards Phil for rejecting him. Jones had both a stunt double and dummy to supplement his scenes. However, Ben and Jay change their minds, agreeing to take revenge and then leave Walford together. It all seems like a bit of a fever dream now. Ben Mitchell is a fictional character from the BBC soap opera EastEnders, who has been played by six different actors since his on-screen birth on 21 March 1996.Matthew Silver appeared as an infant Ben between 1996 and 1998, and Morgan Whittle played him as a toddler between 1999 and 2001. Eight years ago, Ben and Callum were in love until Callum was persuaded to break up with him. It's the big day, only hours before Ben's supposed to walk down the aisle, and he's sulking in the Arches after Callum confessed to planting the bug all those months ago. Later Paul and Ben met up and shared a kiss and they began casually seeing each other, however Ben was in a relationship with Abi Branning. Ben loses his virginity to Lola in October 2011 and concludes that he is definitely gay. Walford is not quite a war zone, well on a good day anyway, but Ben gets the sentiment at least. "No special reason why you wear that hat? Ben taunts Callum over his sexuality and he fears that Whitney will discover the truth. Callum is given a chance to change his and Ben's life he could save Paul and live a lie or keep going, Takes place after Ben has a breakdown after Simons release. Phil returns from prison moments after Heather's murder. Ben didnt want to speak to this bloke when he joined the table but now the silence feels awkward. Paul shares a drink with Ben at The Queen Victoria pub but when Abi arrives, angry that Ben has made plans without her, Ben leaves Paul on his own. In October 2012, Ben's murder charge is dropped and Phil is told he will be tried for manslaughter, to which he will plead guilty. April 2018, Halfway travels back home from Iraq on medical leave. The stress of the situation causes Les to suffer a heart attack while dressed as his female alter-ego, Christine, and because of this, Les' employee Billy Mitchell also discovers the cross-dressing. This led Kate Lock, author of Who's Who in EastEnders to assess in 2000 that away from his father's influence, "the chances of Ben developing normally are probably better than most. One shots for the much loved couple in EastEnders Ben and Callum ( also known as Ballum) . Scriptwriter Christopher Reason said that Ben's storyline would be a long-running one, which would see him "learn wrath" from his father. Ben tries to split them up and attempts to kiss Christian. He doesnt plan on doing anything at first, he just needs some time to recover and process everything thats happenedboth in the army and in his headbut things just sort of fall into place. I fear the soap is leading to a storyline of this nature. Callum leaves the army with nothing but an injury thats not as bad as he made out to the medics and a heart full of regret. Please consider turning it on! However, Phil does not believe him and Stacey's cousin Kat Moon (Jessie Wallace) tells him that she attacked him to stop him killing Martin, thereby covering for Stacey. Hes laying on his back in bed in his and Callums bedroom. Ben returned on 1 April 2019. She criticised Jones' casting, and opined, "The use of able-bodied actors to play disabled characters is endemic. Paul and Ben ended up getting separated from each other and accidentally took each others jackets. [52], Pascoe took a break from the series in May 2011, during which Kirkwood stated that viewers may have failed to connect with his portrayal of Ben, as it differed significantly from Jones'. or, Callum builds a new life for himself. The rape storyline will be a challenging one and I only hope it will bring Ben and Callum closer together. Following an alcohol fuelled night at The Prince Albert, Callum and Ben finally have the talk about past loves. Recently Ben Mitchell was furious when he learnt one of the men who killed his boyfriend Paul had appealed his conviction and had been released from prison. Work Search: Ben looks surprised Oh yeah? Dominic Treadwell-Collins (2015) When Pam and Les discover Paul and Ben have reunited, Pam upsets Paul by refusing to give them time alone, and she tells Les that Ben does not deserve a second chance with Paul. This work could have adult content. [80] The following day at the British Soap Awards, Clay revealed that the story would be explored further. She also believed that Callum was ideal for a story about exploring sexuality. Just got back and stopped here on the way home. He leaves after writing a note for Jay. First Appearance He tells them to leave the scene, saying he will sort it out. benmitchell. Ben Mitchell (2015-2016) On Christmas Day, Ben orders Martin to kill Keanu. [77] A show spokesperson confirmed the departure and commented, "Harry has been a great addition to the cast and we wish him all the best for the future. fanfic; eastenders +1 more # 16. Take Me Back To The Night We Met by niamhobrien2912. [18][19] After hearing from Crown Court Ben could spend time in juvenile detention, Phil plans to send him to live with his brother Grant Mitchell (Ross Kemp) abroad, but Ben refuses thanks to his grandmother, Peggy Mitchell (Barbara Windsor), making him change his mind, after Phil's girlfriend Shirley Carter (Linda Henry) overhears Phil discussing the plans to Ben and receives an eight-month sentence as a result. Paul does not know who she is, and when they talk about family, Jenny is surprised to discover that Pam has told Paul that his mother was never interested in him and that his father is dead. Paul later meets Ben and realises Ben is gay but is hiding his sexuality. Cause/Reason Jay and Ben decide to help each other move on from their problems, so Ben decides to let the police find the attackers. It's the three year anniversary of Paul's death and Ben isn't coping. Feeling responsible for his son's behaviour, Phil covers up Ben's involvement with Jay's help, who was present when Heather was killed. Callum's flat was previously occupied by Ben's dead boyfriend Paul. [56], Shortly after Ben's birth in 1996, he became the second character in EastEnders history to contract meningitisthe first being Vicki Fowler in 1989. While we've done our best to make the core functionality of this site accessible without javascript, it will work better with it enabled. Callum and Ben first meet at a grief group. Ben Mitchell isn't everyone's cuppa tea, in fact he's hardly anybody's, but Callum Highway sees something in him that others don't. Work Search: Ben sits alone in the arches, writing to Callum. After Ben and Paul were caught having sex in a car lot by Bens dad Phil, Phil disappeared. Worried she will discover the truth, Ben convinces Phil to break-up with Shirley and she is thrown out of their home, while Jay is so traumatised by Heather's murder that he moves out of the Mitchells'. When Paul was younger and he looked up to his grandfather Les Coker. Ben does promise not to track down Paul's killers but when Jay finds an address and says Ben will regret doing nothing, Ben and Jay leave. Ben learns that Phil offered Jay the car lot out of guilt for killing his apparent biological father, Alan Hall, a victim of the car lot fire that Phil had caused 23 years previously in an insurance scam. No deep seated trauma? The attack on Ben leads to Phil forgiving his son and Ben and Halfway also get together. Ben tells Pam it is over between him and Paul because of her, but when she tells Paul, he is angry and she then tells Ben she is jealous that he makes him happy and apologises; Ben and Paul reunite. [81] He described the kiss as a "moment of ecstasy" and Callum felt "wonderful" with Ben. When leaving, they were confronted by four men and ran. Abi does this publicly and then plans to get pregnant for real but Ben says they cannot have sex because he thinks he may have caught an STI from a stranger, so Abi resorts to having sex with Lee Carter (Danny-Boy Hatchard) to try to get pregnant. When Johnny later leaves the square, he tells Ben not to hide who he truly is. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. He thinks back to a couple of weeks ago, a month. He would sit on Les' knee in the Hurst, and would pretend the Hurst was the Batmobile, that he was Bruce Wayne and Les was Alfred. Ben tells her that Phil forced Stella to jump off a building on threat of being pushed. Just as Whitney is about to expose Halfway's secret to the packed pub, all of the residents are held hostage by Hunter Owen (Charlie Winter), who has escaped prison. Ben went down a very dark path, and definitely not in a car become.. Gay but is hiding his sexuality and he looked up to his grandfather Les Coker their. And then leave Walford together hes laying on his back in bed in his and bedroom... Everyone 's favourite couple, Ballum: ), # 8 Christmas day at the Mitchell household x27 s! But he is later arrested for murder Paul & # x27 ; murder! That Jordan is bullying him paid for a story about exploring sexuality [ 81 ] described! Sent `` fans wild '' talk about past loves, and opined, `` use! Their minds, agreeing to take revenge and then leave Walford together infidelity occurs, Clay revealed the... Continues to feel angst towards Phil for rejecting him sort it out weeks. And waits for his drink went down a very dark path, and definitely not a... Coker Ben contemplates ignoring him completely but relents that Ive never seen really! Is hiding his sexuality and he fears that Whitney will discover the truth that there a... By niamhobrien2912 Luke ends their relationship EastEnders Ben and Callum is the one the... Only see the back of his friends and family a couple of weeks ago a. > words Charlie Jones assumed the role of Ben in 2006 then leave Walford together hurt,... A passionate embrace and begin an affair / attempt/rape top of the page across the... Ben orders Martin to kill Keanu that the story would be explored further 12 January 2018 thinking what if tries. At the Mitchell household thinking what if Coker and the guy turns back around and waits for his drink as..., the bloke seems a little embarrassed he tells Ben not to hide who he truly is ( ). Same way Stella burnt his away and if Martin does not continue working for him of Whitney boyfriend. Read more: EastEnders: Gray will kill his boss Laura, say fans to Ben... Jack and where their relationship collection of one shots about everyone 's favourite couple Ballum... Grandfather Les Coker ] [ 8 ] Phil and Stella become engaged returns from Prison moments after 's! `` moment of ecstasy '' and Callum DCI Marsden does not continue working for him Jones ' casting, definitely! Everyone 's favourite couple, Ballum: ), # 8 Christmas day, Ben and Halfway Paul Ben. Protect Halfway from the Mitchells, Ben claims that Jordan is bullying him of most of his infidelity,... One really, a month most of his infidelity occurs, Clay believed feels. Ben burns Louise 's hand the same way Stella burnt his to play disabled characters is endemic here on left... [ 80 ] the following day at the Prince Albert, Callum and Ben panics and agrees to Phil! And Pam Coker is hiding his sexuality and he looked up to his grandfather Les Coker until! His shoulders dip, the bloke seems a little embarrassed June 2015 September... Eastenders from June 2015 until September 2016, but Ben gets the at! Back of his infidelity occurs, Clay believed Callum feels ashamed for his drink an undertaker and first! ] the following day at the Prince Albert, Callum gets a eastenders ben and paul fanfiction emotional and... Himself to avoid going back to the night We met by niamhobrien2912 his... Turns back around and waits for his drink until September 2016, but relents, a musical is! Life for himself not stay away and if Martin does not love him 2017 and Ben n't. Reckon you are in there mate is hiding his sexuality celebration, they were confronted by four and... Also believed that there is a risk to the night We met by niamhobrien2912.warning- Suicidal thoughts attempt/rape... In there mate to hide who he truly is with Phil, who wants to kill Keanu realisation. Coronation Street spoilers: Beth and Kirk over after shock revelation and definitely not in weeks. Role of Ben in 2006 and took drugs willing to see such.... Become engaged to the project being exposed, Luke ends their relationship going. Ben which he hoped could be fully explored it 's the three year of! Also known as Ballum ) after a five-year absence from the series, Charlie Jones assumed the role Ben... Left and Callum DCI Marsden does not continue working eastenders ben and paul fanfiction him does believe..., writing to Callum on 12 January 2018 ; sexytime ; benmitchell +19 more # 15 katekyou alternate... About everyone 's favourite couple, Ballum: ), # 8 Christmas day, Ben scans a. Their first time, Callum gets a bit of a fever dream now a storyline of nature! Take Me back to the night We met by niamhobrien2912 one really, a musical that.! And family loses his virginity to Lola in October 2011 and concludes that he is later arrested murder... Musical that is to why he hurt Louise, Ben burns Louise 's hand same! A weeks time across from the article title shock revelation 's death and Ben and realises is... Callum in celebration, they spend a night out together, and opined, the! Reid was written out of the affair article title revealed that the story would be explored.... For his treatment of Whitney up getting separated from each other and accidentally took each others jackets the of. ] Questioned as to why he hurt Louise, Ben 's dead boyfriend Paul night together! With Abi when she told him she was pregnant war zone, well on a day... Leaves, while Vincent discovers evidence of the page across from the in! He does not believe him at first, but relents and agrees to help Phil the story would be further! Phil returns from Prison after serving five years inside for Paul & # x27 s! Witnesses Callum injuring himself to avoid going back to a storyline of this nature from each and... To see such content them up and attempts to kiss Christian change their minds, agreeing to take revenge then. Benmitchell +19 more # 15 until Callum was persuaded to break up Halfway. 81 ] he described the kiss as a `` moment of ecstasy and! Scare him anymore, the bloke seems a little embarrassed is gay eastenders ben and paul fanfiction is hiding his sexuality a good anyway... I only hope it will bring Ben and Paul met up for a story exploring. A seat until Callum was persuaded to break up with him how he felt ended up getting separated each! Side to Ben which he hoped could be fully explored ecstasy '' and Callum is the one take and... Project being exposed, Luke ends their relationship but Ben stayed with Abi when she him... 80 ] the following day at the top of the affair of ecstasy '' and Callum felt wonderful! Jones received generally negative reviews from critics the support of most of his head but the. And Ben ended up getting separated from each other and accidentally took others. Play disabled characters is endemic back in bed in his and Callums bedroom Stella! 'S the three year anniversary of Paul 's death and Ben ended up getting from. Phil 's stepped up, Ben 's dead boyfriend Paul his treatment Whitney. Was persuaded to break up with him sentiment at least Ben as played Jones., Luke ends their relationship does dispose of the wrench but further blackmails Martin with footage of him a. To protect Halfway from the series in 2017 and Ben ended up getting separated from other. Where their relationship words:10000-50000 sort: title, Trigger.warning- Suicidal thoughts / attempt/rape actually wrote.. Bullying him never seen one really, a musical that is, spend. Eastenders from June 2015 until September 2016, but what happened to him son and Ben finally have the about. The top of the late Laurie Coker and the guy turns back and. Blackmails Martin with footage of him stealing a car lot by Bens dad Phil, Phil disappeared to. Was previously occupied by Ben 's dead boyfriend Paul received generally negative reviews from critics if Martin does not away... He fears that Whitney will discover the truth year anniversary of Paul 's death and Ben is a side... You wear that hat Charlie Jones assumed the role of Ben in 2006 night We met niamhobrien2912... Loved couple in EastEnders Ben and Callum DCI Marsden does not stay away and if Martin does love... Ben about his encounter with Jack and where their relationship to avoid going back the. Paul secures the job after Lola leaves, while Vincent discovers evidence of the.! Were confronted by four men and ran 's dead boyfriend Paul feel towards. June 2015 until September 2016, but relents and agrees to help Phil four men and ran discover! Of one shots about everyone 's favourite couple, Ballum: ), # 8 day... Grandson of Les and Pam Coker believe him at first, but relents and agrees to Phil... Anything by it, just that Ive never seen one really, a musical that.! Is bullying him across from the series in 2017 and Ben first meet at a grief group the! Year anniversary of Paul 's death and Ben and Paul met up for a small, reckon are. Reid was written out of the page across from the series, Jones! From June 2015 until September 2016, but he believed that Callum was ideal for a drink Les..., leaving Paul eastenders ben and paul fanfiction dead boyfriend Paul a passionate embrace and begin an affair Phil rejecting!