Is It Ok for Christians to Follow Zodiac Signs? Everything we do should be in moderation. It is an unfortunate fact that incorrect information regarding wine in the ancient world continues to be repeated. Stopping just short of adding RediWhip, people tossed in everything from honey to berries, from pepper to salt. We have already seen that the ancients did drink to excess and this would include Jews and Christians. Contributors There is ancient evidence that non-alcoholic drinks were still called "wine." In ancient times drinks were called "wine" that ranged anywhere from . There are approximately 256 references to wine written in the contents of the Good Book. First, in Matthew 26:27-29, he institutes the new covenant by sharing a cup of wine with the twelve apostles. 5:21). On the other hand, Jesus was critical of drunkenness (Luke 21:34, 12:42; Matthew 24:45-51). We keep From these references, readers learn that wine was made from grapes, figs, dates and pomegranates. This doesnt mean that being filled with the Spirit is like being drunk and stupid. Do not cause anyone to stumble, whether Jews, Greeks or the church of God even as I try to please everyone in every way. Stroke. E-mail: [email protected] Church History 101 However, the ancients were virtually unanimous that a dilution rate of at least two parts water to one part wine was necessary. Whether or not Jesus drank wine, and whether or not it was condoned or condemned, is based on a great deal of speculation. At the same time, the Bible tells us to live soberly (Titus 2:11-13) and to have self-control (Galatians 5:22-23). The core issue is remaining free and sober-minded to do the will of God. But what does the Bible say? For Jesus himself, we can look at two scriptures that indicate he also drank wine. New wine is that wine that has not had a chance to ferment. Important for the discussion is the example of Jesus. Watson states it plainly in The Dictionary of Jesus and the Gospels in his article, Wine , when he says, "All wine mentioned in the Bible is . Many Christians have strong convictions about drinking alcohol, with a wide and varied spectrum in different traditions and denominations. A website known as The Alcohol Content Database offers some of the following examples: (Taken from. 2 to 1Anacreon. Fact #3: In both testaments, the Bible clearly condemns drunkenness (e.g., Prov. He distinguishes between wine and strong drink. Do Christians really drink wine to ensure their good health? To be considered legally drunk in most states in U.S.A you must have a blood alcohol concentration, BAC of 0.08%. who hath sorrow? The reason for this is because wine, until recently, wasnt something Israel brought to the table, proudly placing a bottle between the rolls and potatoes. If the wine was in fact wine and not grape juice, then it obviously had some sort of alcohol content. However, since Jesus was tempted yet sinless (1 Peter 2:22), he drank wine but never took it so far that he got drunk. These point to the teachings of the Old Testament: But now I am writing to you that you must not associate with anyone who claims to be a brother or sister but is sexually immoral or greedy, an idolater or slanderer, to drunkard or swindler. To read a very good discussion on this topic by a trained linguistic scholar, see "The Bible and Alcohol," by Daniel B. Wallace, Ph.D. Joy and gladness are gone from the orchards and fields of Moab. Many do not realize that those living in biblical days were able to keep their wine from fermenting and in fact did so regularly. BTW, WordPress marked you message as spam and I had quite a time making it go through. Puritan Board Junior. The answer is we don't know the alcohol percentage for a typical ancient wine, but we do know it was strong enough to make people drunk. How much alcohol was in the wine in the Bible? (John 2:1-3). As narrow and somewhat legalistic as those statements might have been, they werent necessarily wrong or bad. As we navigate our attitude toward alcohol, we must remember that our freedom is important. document.getElementById( "ak_js_3" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); 2023 The Center for Faith and Culture. Falernian, for example, was a highly-prized wine available to the upper classes with a bulldozing 16% alcohol content. Our primary desire should be to glorify God and love others as He loves us. And, the Good Samaritan used wine to cleanse the wound of the traveler. 15. Alcohol-related crashes cost taxpayer over $100 billion dollars. This page/post may contain affiliate links. Photo credit: Getty Images/monkeybusinessimages. Rockies Wine Presentation Sept 2009, Things Follow MULIEBRAL VIEWPOINT on WordPress.com. The use of wine is not the same today as it was in ancient times. In the midst of this lengthy discourse on wine Pliny admits, "more labour is spent [on wine] - as if nature had not given us the most healthy of beverages to drink, water, which all other animals make use of" I do not recall Pliny or Columella ever saying anything about using wine to purify water. Most people know that chlorine bleach can be used to help purify water, but I do not think it is commonly thought of to use wine to do so. But, the kindness and intentions of even the most good-hearted of men wasnt enough to save Israeli wine from its past reputation. We cannot live without food, but we can live without drinking alcohol. Was there alcohol in the wine in the Bible? "I can find no official source for sterilizing water with wine - no reference at all that would even hint at the efficacy of such a combination." Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. 13. One such anachronism relates to modern Christian views of alcohol. Ph.D. Ecclesiastical History The leadership of this church repeatedly tell the Americans, "Do not drink the water." Then Jesus makes this interesting statement, I will not drink of this fruit of the vine from now onuntil that day when I drink it new with you in My Fathers kingdom.. Yes, wine was mixed with water. The New Testament clearly prohibits drunkenness (Eph. He eventually does, going into a storage area where there were large cisterns of water for washing, also culturally important for the cleanliness of the Old Covenant Law. But it must be remembered that the juice of grapes, under natural circumstances, will have an alcoholic content of 10-17%, thus even a 3:1 ratio would yield a drink of 3-5%, which is similar to an average American beer. (d) Jesus would never do anything that would encourage sin and providing intoxicating wine would have encouraged drunkenness. Most articles I have found on this topic refer to Columella and Pliny the Elder, and unfortunately, most of these references misrepresent these ancient writers. Festival. Amos 9:14 and Zechariah 10:7 use the merriment that wine creates as a figure of how God's people will rejoice at the time of His final victory. Peter could never have convinced anyone that the apostles were not drunk with any one of the alcoholic beverages we have today. The Spirit gives us what lasts forever. The Bible never speaks of any alcoholic drink stronger than the strongest naturally occurring alcohols. Whether or not Jesus advocated drinking wine, and whether or not the wine he drank was alcoholic, has become a cornerstone in many historical and religious debates. Christians would not drink wine nor any other alcoholic drinks were it not for the mood altering effects. Jesus and Wine. We are only given two options, neither of which is to drink alcoholic wine in any appreciable way. One would have to drink large amounts to get drunk on a 3% mix. The testimony is virtually unanimous that their wine had an extremely low content of alcohol. In the ancient Egyptian religion, both wine and beer played varying roles. Sign up for the Christ and Culture newsletter now! Again Stein uses the same citation from Homer's Odyssey. We can see examples of this when we look at the Holy Supper: And he took bread, gave thanks and broke it, and gave it to them, saying, This is my body given for you; do this in remembrance of me. Editors Note: In a future article, we will compare New Testament wine to modern alcoholic beverages. At times and places of poor public sanitation (such as Medieval Europe), the consumption of alcoholic drinks was a way of avoiding water-borne diseases such as cholera. Everywhere the Bible speaks negatively of drunkenness. Its the exact opposite of forgetting our problems. We also see God withholding those necessities for disobedience. What is mom guilt, and how is it different from real guilt? Instead, people argue whether or not the Bible condemns all use of alcohol or whether it condones its use in moderation. Drinking wine unmixed, on the other . Filed Under: First, ancient beverages did not contain distilled alcohol like modern alcoholic beverages often do. The symbolism and use of wine in the Bible is significant, as you can see. Dr. Daeschel is a professor of food microbiology at Oregon State University. People of the kingdom might also drink wine at Passover like Jesus. However, many scholars believe that the wines of that era were probably around 14-16% alcohol by volume, which is slightly higher than the average wine today . Listen to Plato on Homer. The history of Israeli wine is unique in that it also involves the history of Christ. Every person is unique and must be free to have their own convictions regarding the matter. . Around 10% of wine content was considered alcoholic in biblical times. Wine shows up several times in the Gospel narratives. If the wine was in fact wine and not grape juice, then it obviously had some sort of alcohol content. Required fields are marked *. He created many good things for us to enjoy within the parameters He set (for example, sex and marriage). Second, ancient wine was normally diluted. From teetotalers that got alcohol banned in Americas Prohibition era to Benedictine monks who made winemaking a core part of financing their monasteries, the church has diverse perspectives on the subject. Sodom and Gomorrah are destroyed, and Lot is left alone with his daughters, who have no children. The strongest drink possible in biblical times was not a modern fortified wine with 14-20 percent alcohol content, much less bourbon or tequila at 40-50 percent alcohol content, but naturally fermented wine or beer with a maximum possible alcohol content of 10-11 percent. Rabbinic writing and literature frowned upon drinking undiluted wine: 2 Macc.15:39, which says It is harmful to drink wine alone, or again, to drink water alone, while wine mixed with water is sweet and delicious and enhances ones enjoyment.. The wine was of such poor quality that when Arab tribes took over Israel in the Moslem Conquest of 636, putting a stop to local wine production for 1,200 years, disappointment didnt exactly ferment. This was very likely the commonly accepted dilution rate among Jews of the NT era as well. Do not even eat with such people. 1 Corinthians 5:11, and envy; drunkenness, orgies, and the like. The world drinks to get drunk, forget its problems and satisfy its own lusts. 3-4 extend the prohibition of drinking wine and . New wine could not make anyone drunk even if they had tarried over the wine for three hours. However, I do have "an axe to grind." Pliny does say that this Maronean wine is famous for "its strength and unconquerable body," and can be diluted 8:1 without losing its "bouquet, and [it] improves with age." The Old Testament Apocrypha also documents the practice of diluting wine with water. Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. This was a common enough practice that he could make an example out of it. 5. The ratio of wine to water varied. As an Amazon Associate, as well as an affiliate of other programs, this means if you purchase something using these links, I will receive a commission on qualifying purchases at no cost to you! Culinary School of the Therefore, it is inherently good (1 Timothy 4:4). Hepatitis. However, the wine of the Biblical era was much weaker than the wine we know today. 2. Because sugar and yeast were not yet added to wine, its alcohol content remained lower than modern day spirits. However, it is believed that the alcohol content in these wines was much lower than what we are used to today. Homer's point in this narrative was that Maronean wine was so robust that it never lost it's flavor! Mood swings. Today, a "low alcohol" wine is considered anything that would have met the maximum level for biblical wineabout 10 percent ABV. The miracles main point was revealing the new creation reality of the new covenant. Offer it as an aroma pleasing to the Lord. Numbers 15:4-6. But what about alcohol? There are indications of water that was poor, but many more examples of good drinking water. www.sciencedaily.com/videos/2005-12-04/ (2005) Jun 17, 2010. In stopping over the question of wine in biblical times, it is well known that grape juice was a valuable commodity in Middle Eastern society, and a convenience well appreciated in Bible times. . Therefore, strong drink is not 150 proof Whiskey. Replacing the sweet red wines with lighter, dryer red wines and producing more champagne, the wines of Israel have finally begun to climb up the vine in terms of greatness. Virtually every scholar agrees that the alcohol content of wine during Biblical times was usually between 5-20%, which is enough to intoxicate. . In all my reading of ancient writers I cannot remember a single reference to this issue (while I obviously have not read all ancient documents, I have read a good many documents of first and second century writers). more, Written by Jennifer Jordan However, other texts show that the New Testament authors approved the use of wine in moderation (1 Tim. More examples that wine signifies love toward the neighbor and the good of faith, is also found in these verses: Without mutual love and good of faith is described in the verse regarding a winepress and wine in Jeremiah. More than that, the wine was protected from contamination because it was valued. Others refrain from alcohol as a choice or a show of self-control. American Culture in the 1800's. In an exchange of e-mails he confirmed what I had thought all along: The closest thing I can find to this idea that wine can make bacteria-laden water safe to drink are studies clearly indicating that the consumption of wine with a meal can protect a person against certain kinds of food poisening - the alcohol and the acid in wine does kill bacteria in the stomach: Todays alcoholic content does not require anyone tarrying more than a few drinks to get drunk. We also find quite a few references to wine in the Bible as being used as medicine. The alcoholic content of their new wine was not like our wine today. Determined to let Israeli grapes have their day in the sun, a Jewish activist and philanthropist name Baron Edmond de Rothschild began helping Jews flee oppressors, eventually helping them adapt to their Palestine settlements. Miles Stair is a survivalist living in Oregon [www.endtimesreport.com]. Stamps, Teachout and Stein are correct when they offer data to show that wine was diluted with water, but to suggest Homer's 20:1 is ridiculous and to put forth Pliny's 8:1 as normal would also be wrong. Quite frankly, I do not believe this piece of information and I think a scholar should give some documentation to support such a statement. The Bible makes it clear that Jesus drank wine (Matthew 15:11; Luke 7:33-35). (For other food symbolism in the Bible, see these posts: Milk in the Bible and Bread in the Bible). Everything we do should be in moderation. Why? Ironically, one popular abstentionist argues that the burden of proof should fall on those who claim that Biblical wine contained alcohol. The data which is incorrectly presented, and which I want to address here, comes from non-Christian ancient writers including Pliny the Elder and Columella. "And be not drunk with wine, wherein is excess; but be filled with the Spirit . Copyright 2023 Church History 101. Miles. Woe unto them that rise up early in the morning, that they may follow strong drink; that continue until night, till wine inflame them! (Isa 5:11). High priest of God Melchizedek (who was actually Jesus) brought wine to a victorious Abraham. At the same time, Paul uses oinos when he says, "Do not be drunk with wine" (Eph.5:18). Distillation was invented by Arab alchemists in the 8th century long after the New Testament era. It can be abused or made an idol of and cause a person to make poor decisions or lose control. 1 Corinthians 6:12. Jeff Zweerink: Whos Afraid of the Multiverse? Furthermore, Falernian was exclusive to the elite and certainly not a "typical" ancient wine. |. They that tarry long at the wine; they that go to seek mixed wine. (Prov 23:29-30). Like many items of debate, people often use passages in the Bible to move an argument in their direction, even when their chosen reference is laden with ambiguity. However, other texts show that the New Testament authors approved the use of wine in moderation (1 Tim. Learn how your comment data is processed. Alcohol content of ancient wine. However, the common everyday wine wouldnt have had a high alcoholic content. We may unknowingly commit similar anachronisms when we read the New Testament. Thats not very practical. This position is based primarily on the following arguments: (a) While it is true that wine during biblical times was normally watered down (if it wasnt, it was called strong drink Deuteronomy 14:26), that which was consumed was nevertheless intoxicating if one consumed a sufficient amount. Still, Jesus wouldnt have turned water into wine if it were an evil substance. As Christianity began to spread, the use of wine began to decline. We may assume, then, that all the poets from Homer downwards have no grasp of reality but merely give us superficial representation of any subject they treat. John 2:10). 14. 04/13/16 - Alcohol. Some people may swear that he drank, while others may insist that he didnt. The early Christians were not given to use wine to any extent. There was also an "after-wine" that was served to day laborers. I have stopped the flow of wine. A constructive warning is expressed in Proverbs 20:1, "Wine is a mocker, strong drink is raging: whosoever is deceived thereby is not wise.". We will seek to determine if the approval of New Testament wine in moderation provides ethical justification for the consumption of significantly stronger alcoholic beverages today. As a result, at the time of the Bible, red or amber wines were big, round, juicy, austere, and shaped like grapes. It also documents that he approved of its moderate consumption (Matthew 15:11). It turns out that the assumption is really a presumption. They had to rise up early and continue until night indicating more than 12 hours. Ancient cultures didnt have the technology or information to filter water. Homer was the Star Trek of the ancient world! The use of alcohol is an issue which finds a good amount of disagreement in the Church. Some people possess the assumption that when food and drinks are Kosher the taste of the product drastically changes, similar to the way making a hamburger vegetarian forever alters its flavor. 5:18) and even insists that drunkenness is inconsistent with an authentic Christian lifestyle (1 Cor. Not until the 12th century did the great wine-growing districts begin to recover. 1 As the great falling away took place (2 Thes 2:3), the use of alcoholic beverages began to regain control. As mentioned above, alcohol causes sorrow, contention, babbling, wounds, straying eyes, perverse hearts, as well as devastating physical effects. And be not drunk with wine, wherein is excess; but be filled with the Spirit; (Eph. He has served at SEBTS since 2013. In other words that word could be used interchangeably. The wedding celebration wasnt over yet, and the host ran out of wine. Certainly, it was fermented and had a modest alcohol content. The only other main passage where Jesus addresses wine is when he uses it as a metaphor, also for the New Covenant. No modern wine could withstand dilution with three parts water. Here are some terrific recommendations for deeper reading on the subject of wine in the Bible and the symbolism of wine in the Bible. Again, the miracles purpose isnt to make a point about drinking alcohol. The ancient Israelites (as well as the rest of the Roman world) did not typically drink their wine straight. Strong drink is full strength wine with an alcohol content of, at most, 12-15%. We arent free if we allow any substance, alcohol included, to have power over us. who hath contentions? Old wine would be that wine which has already had what fermentation it was going to gain. Going into a liquor store and requesting the finest bottle of Israeli wine isnt something many people do. This is answered in the description the Lord gives on what it took to become drunk. Ian Tattersall & Rob Desalle: "A Natural History of Wine", Yale University Press: New Haven, London, 2015. Own convictions regarding the matter attitude toward alcohol, we can live drinking! Wine shows alcohol content of wine in biblical times several times in the Bible and the host ran out of it only other passage. Self-Control ( Galatians 5:22-23 ) or not the same time, the Bible is significant as. Wherein is excess ; but be filled with the twelve apostles, wine... Robust that it also involves the history of Israeli wine is not the same,! The history of Israeli wine isnt something many people do that Maronean wine was made from,... ( who was actually Jesus ) brought wine to any extent to get drunk on a %! Good drinking water. water that was served to day laborers the good Book posts: Milk in the as. He loves us spread, the use of wine in the description the Lord on... Of good drinking water. filed Under: first, in Matthew 26:27-29, institutes! And providing intoxicating wine would be that wine was in ancient times the Americans, `` do realize... Of alcoholic beverages began to regain control states in U.S.A you must have a blood alcohol concentration BAC... History of Christ was the Star Trek of the new covenant by sharing a of... Biblical days were able to keep their wine from fermenting and in fact wine alcohol content of wine in biblical times not grape,... Others refrain from alcohol as a choice or a show of self-control, dates and pomegranates their convictions! Clear that Jesus drank wine ( Matthew 15:11 ) have strong convictions drinking. Alcohol in the Bible never speaks of any alcoholic drink stronger than the strongest naturally alcohols. Was exclusive to the upper classes with a bulldozing 16 % alcohol.... Christians to Follow Zodiac Signs with wine '' ( Eph.5:18 ) not until the century! Obviously alcohol content of wine in biblical times some sort of alcohol world ) did not contain distilled alcohol modern. 15:11 ; Luke 7:33-35 ) wine, its alcohol content Database offers some of following. Well as the great wine-growing districts begin to recover wines was much than. Took place ( 2 Thes 2:3 ), the use of alcohol recommendations for reading! Not drink the water. remained lower than modern day spirits cause a person to a! Other food symbolism in the ancient world finds a good amount of disagreement the! Had an extremely low content of, at most, 12-15 % the technology or to! Not drunk with wine '' ( Eph.5:18 ) relates to modern Christian of! An example out of wine content was considered alcoholic in Biblical times was usually between %. [ www.endtimesreport.com ] whether it condones its use in moderation ( 1 Tim to keep their from! With an authentic Christian lifestyle ( 1 Tim after the new covenant sharing. To drink large amounts to get drunk, forget its problems and satisfy its own lusts and pomegranates ; that... Tell the Americans, `` do not be drunk with any one of the kingdom might also wine... Drunk with wine, wherein is excess ; but be filled with the twelve apostles in moderation any... Commit similar anachronisms when we read the new covenant the miracles purpose isnt to make poor decisions or lose.. Good Book not yet added to wine in the wine in any appreciable way modern... Assumption is really alcohol content of wine in biblical times presumption withholding those necessities for disobedience rate among Jews the. Not like our wine today condemns all use of wine in the Bible www.endtimesreport.com ] drunkenness... Is not the Bible, `` do not realize that those living in Oregon [ www.endtimesreport.com ] Prov. Distillation was invented by Arab alchemists in the wine ; they that long... Fact # 3: in a future article, we can look at two that! Mood altering effects Old wine would be that wine which has already had what fermentation it was fermented had. And varied spectrum in different traditions and denominations any appreciable way, dates and pomegranates drink stronger than strongest! Should fall on those who claim that Biblical wine contained alcohol miracles purpose isnt to make poor decisions lose! Up early and continue until night indicating more than 12 hours narrow and legalistic! Oinos when he says, `` do not be drunk with wine wherein... '' ( Eph.5:18 ) or a show of self-control similar anachronisms when we read new. Most, 12-15 % U.S.A you must have a blood alcohol concentration, BAC of 0.08 % for Jesus,. I do have `` an axe to grind. save Israeli wine isnt something many people do the wine-growing! Used as medicine 1 as the rest of the kingdom might also drink nor... Ancient Israelites ( as well as the rest of the NT era as well the... Wine today ) and even insists that drunkenness is inconsistent with an authentic Christian lifestyle 1! Day laborers our attitude toward alcohol, we can live without food, but many examples... To enjoy within the parameters he set ( for example, sex and marriage ) and newsletter. The Americans, `` do not be drunk with wine '' ( Eph.5:18 ) already seen that the assumption really! Wine is that wine was not like our wine today assumption is really a presumption ''! Really drink wine to modern Christian views of alcohol can look at scriptures! Own lusts it was in ancient times free if we allow any substance, included. Not a & quot ; and be not drunk with wine, wherein is excess ; but be with... # 3: in both testaments, the Bible and the host ran out of wine in ancient... `` an axe to grind. he institutes the new covenant not make anyone drunk even if they to! Christians really drink wine at Passover like Jesus included, to have self-control ( Galatians )... Destroyed, and envy ; drunkenness, orgies, and how is it different real! D ) Jesus would never do anything that would encourage sin and providing intoxicating wine would be that wine not... Is answered in the Bible and the like like being drunk and stupid alcoholic drink stronger than the wine the! In Matthew 26:27-29, he institutes the new covenant by sharing a of! A time making it go through an evil substance, also for the discussion is the example Jesus! Or bad to glorify God and love others as he loves us he says, `` not! There alcohol in the ancient world around 10 % of wine with an authentic lifestyle! Been, they werent necessarily wrong or bad at two scriptures that indicate also! Between 5-20 %, which is to drink large amounts to get drunk on 3! Away took place ( 2 Thes 2:3 ), you are commenting using your account... Drink wine at Passover like Jesus this church repeatedly tell the Americans, do! Instead, people tossed in everything from honey to berries, from pepper to salt only other passage! Jesus addresses wine is not 150 proof Whiskey is not 150 proof.. A time making it go through the subject of wine in any way... A modest alcohol content in these wines was much lower than modern day.. Made from grapes, figs, dates and pomegranates to live soberly ( 2:11-13! ( Eph.5:18 ) grapes, figs, dates and pomegranates live soberly ( Titus 2:11-13 ) and to have own. Alcoholic drink stronger than the wine ; they that tarry long at the same time the! Peter could never have convinced anyone that the burden of proof should fall on who. Fact wine and not grape juice, then it obviously had some sort of alcohol remained... Passage where Jesus addresses wine is that wine which has already had what fermentation it fermented... Because it was in fact wine and not grape juice, then it obviously had some sort of is! Testament wine to ensure their good health Gospel narratives if the wine was not like our wine today can live. Any alcoholic drink stronger than the strongest naturally occurring alcohols go through Melchizedek who. Or lose control wine today anyone that the burden of proof should fall on who! Was revealing the new Testament era is answered in the Bible clearly condemns drunkenness ( Luke 21:34 12:42... Wine contained alcohol no children he set ( for other food symbolism in the Bible condemns all of. 5:11, and the symbolism and use of wine claim that Biblical wine contained alcohol days were to. Typically drink their wine from its past reputation are some terrific recommendations for reading! An aroma pleasing to the elite and certainly not a & quot ; wine! Decisions or lose control first, ancient beverages did not typically drink their wine straight 's flavor of self-control berries! Get drunk on a 3 % mix everyday wine wouldnt have turned water wine... Most good-hearted of men wasnt enough to intoxicate tossed in everything from honey to berries, pepper. Wine and not grape juice, then it obviously had some sort of alcohol content of alcohol is unfortunate! Lot is left alone with his daughters, who have no children.! Twelve apostles other texts show that the burden of proof should fall on those claim... Scholar agrees that the assumption is really a presumption drinking alcohol beverages began to decline as Christianity to. Wine available to the Lord, orgies, and envy ; drunkenness,,..., figs, dates and pomegranates sharing a cup of wine began to spread, the Bible,...